FANS AND FILM · Reporting
Do fans shape Hollywood? Belgian experts on the new Hunger Games film
As Sunrise on the Reaping plays in Belgian cinemas, researchers from the VUB and UGent say fan campaigns matter mainly indirectly.
Published: · Content updated:
Based on: VRT NWS

Saved articles and followed stories stay in this browser. No account sync or notifications.
Reporting
A fan favourite gets the part
The Hunger Games prequel Sunrise on the Reaping is showing in Belgian cinemas, and VRT NWS reported that one of its casting choices has revived a question: do fans shape the film industry? Fans had tipped McKenna Grace for the role of Maysilee Donner before any official announcement, and she was eventually cast. Florian Stegen, a doctoral researcher at the ECHO research group at the VUB, told VRT NWS that the influence of fan communities is mainly indirect, while Stijn Joye, a film and media scholar at UGent, described social media as a way for studios to gauge the mood.
Reporting
Casting is not a popularity vote
The picture described by the experts is a mixed one. According to VRT NWS, directors do look at which names fans mention online, but Stegen said they never cast someone purely because fans name them. The lead role of Haymitch Abernathy went to Joseph Zada, an Australian actor who is still relatively unknown to the wider public. Joye explained that unknown actors give a studio more control over agreements, for example for sequels. Stegen added that the creative decision ultimately remains decisive, since a lesser-known actor may have the talent that the creative team considers necessary to carry a franchise.
Reporting
Louder voices, closer contact
Social media has strongly changed the influence of fans in recent years, Stegen told VRT NWS: their voices have become louder, and anyone can voice an opinion online or, in some cases, even speak directly with a director. Fans also create visibility for films by posting and talking about them on TikTok and Instagram, and some posts go viral. By following those reactions, studios learn what fans expect and which characters are popular. Joye said the contact has become almost one-to-one communication between the film sector and fans, and a source of data that makers previously had hardly any access to.
Reporting
What the effect on cinema attendance is, and is not
Measuring the effect on ticket sales is difficult. Joye said it is hard to determine exactly how many extra cinemagoers social media brings, although online reviews and reactions increasingly influence whether people choose to see a film, especially people who are less familiar with a franchise than its fans. A small film depends even more on word of mouth, he said, whereas a major franchise such as The Hunger Games already has a loyal fanbase on which studios can count. Stegen cautioned that social media reactions do not always reflect the whole film audience, because the loudest voices tend to be heard most strongly.
People, places and organisations in this story
File pictures of subjects named in the article, not pictures of the events reported.



Sources and factual attribution (1)
- Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS Nieuws — VRT NWS
Dated report by VRT NWS used for the facts attributed to it.
Source publication date: . Consulted: .
Supports
According to VRT NWS, the Hunger Games prequel Sunrise on the Reaping premiered in New York on a Monday and is showing in Belgian cinemas.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS NieuwsVRT NWS reported that fans favoured McKenna Grace for the role of Maysilee Donner before the official casting announcement, and she was eventually cast.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS NieuwsFlorian Stegen of the VUB says the influence of fan communities is mainly indirect: directors see which names are mentioned but never cast someone purely because fans name them.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS NieuwsStijn Joye of UGent says studios mainly use social media as an extra way to gauge online how fans will react to decisions.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS NieuwsThe role of Haymitch Abernathy is played by Joseph Zada, an Australian actor still relatively unknown to the wider public; Stijn Joye says unknown actors give a studio more control over agreements such as sequels.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS NieuwsFlorian Stegen says fans' voices have become louder, and fans create extra visibility for films through TikTok and Instagram; Stijn Joye describes the contact between the film sector and fans as almost one-to-one communication.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS NieuwsStijn Joye says it is hard to measure how many extra cinemagoers social media brings, while Florian Stegen cautions that the loudest voices online do not always reflect the whole film audience.
VRT NWS: Fans wilden McKenna Grace in 'The Hunger Games' en kregen hun zin: luisteren filmstudio's naar fans? | VRT NWS Nieuws
How this article was prepared
Revisions and corrections
No corrections recorded.
- First version · 1 —
First publication.
